Difference between revisions of "Talk:Suggestions"

From Empires Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Why is this page needed in the Wiki?)
 
Line 1: Line 1:
Wiki is a repository of information about the game, not a place to post suggestions for changing it.  This content really belongs in the Suggestions forum and not on the Wiki.  Furthermore, this page might give new players the wrong idea that all of these suggestions are either currently in development or are seriously being considered as new features.  The "Discussion" sections might even turn into forum-like debates, which have no place on the Wiki, imho.  Krenzo and Beerdude should make the final determination of whether or not the page should stay, but I'd delete it. --[[User:Chahk|Chahk]] 09:07, 31 December 2007 (PST)
Wiki is a repository of information about the game, not a place to post suggestions for changing it.  This content really belongs in the Suggestions forum and not on the Wiki.  Furthermore, this page might give new players the wrong idea that all of these suggestions are either currently in development or are seriously being considered as new features.  The "Discussion" sections might even turn into forum-like debates, which have no place on the Wiki, imho.  Krenzo and Beerdude should make the final determination of whether or not the page should stay, but I'd delete it. --[[User:Chahk|Chahk]] 09:07, 31 December 2007 (PST)
i agree 100% with chahk. Furthermore, if the devs don't immediately like a suggestion, I'm willing to bet that they're not even going to CONSIDER it unless the community gives a LOT of feedback on the issue, with most of it positive. This is not the place for such feedback. What COULD be useful is a list of things suggested thousands of times before, and why this suggestion was shot down.--[[User:The Buttery Lobster|The Buttery Lobster]] 01:19, 10 January 2008 (PST)

Revision as of 02:19, 10 January 2008

Wiki is a repository of information about the game, not a place to post suggestions for changing it. This content really belongs in the Suggestions forum and not on the Wiki. Furthermore, this page might give new players the wrong idea that all of these suggestions are either currently in development or are seriously being considered as new features. The "Discussion" sections might even turn into forum-like debates, which have no place on the Wiki, imho. Krenzo and Beerdude should make the final determination of whether or not the page should stay, but I'd delete it. --Chahk 09:07, 31 December 2007 (PST)

i agree 100% with chahk. Furthermore, if the devs don't immediately like a suggestion, I'm willing to bet that they're not even going to CONSIDER it unless the community gives a LOT of feedback on the issue, with most of it positive. This is not the place for such feedback. What COULD be useful is a list of things suggested thousands of times before, and why this suggestion was shot down.--The Buttery Lobster 01:19, 10 January 2008 (PST)